Blog

Calling Women ‘Cautious Investors’ Is Wrong. Here’s What They Really Need to Hear

Women Investors

Too often, women are labeled ‘cautious investors¹’, and many have internalized the stereotype. But research shows a different story: when women invest, they often match or outperform men²

Still, the reality is that outdated myths, systemic barriers and a male-dominated financial industry hold many back from participating fully. Women have long faced systemic barriers to wealth building – from lower pay and costly childcare to career interruptions for caregiving and a greater reliance on part-time work. Add to that persistent shortfalls in financial education and literacy, and it’s no surprise many women find it harder to save and invest consistently. 

Labelling them cautious, however, can present another barrier. “Calling women ‘cautious’ often gets heard as unknowledgeable or risk averse, and this can erode confidence and discourage participation in investing,” says Sue-May Talbot, Portfolio Manager and Partner at Genus. 

Surveys show³ only 33% of women identify as investors, and just 42% feel confident in choosing investments aligned with their goals. Common wealth management approaches often leave women feeling unheard, spoken down to or sold products that don’t reflect their unique needs. Over time, this can chip away at their confidence.

The consequences are serious: in Canada, nearly half of women report having less than $5,000 in savings, which not only puts their ability to retire at risk, but also exposes them to financial pressures in day-to-day life. “What’s more,” Talbot adds, “women live longer on average, which means they need to save even more for retirement.”

None of these challenges reflect women’s abilities as investors – yet they often limit their opportunities to participate fully in investing. It’s time to rewrite the narrative and acknowledge that, when given the chance, women are instinctively capable investors despite the barriers they face. Here’s why:

They’re naturally disciplined

Women and Finance

Women often gravitate toward long-term investing strategies – the same approach we recommend to clients saving for retirement or a family legacy. Even in volatile markets, they tend to stay the course, resisting impulsive moves and focusing on steady growth. “Rather than ‘cautious,’ I see women as deliberate investors,” Talbot says. “They tend to be disciplined, risk aware, focused and diversified, which is exactly what good investing looks like.”

A recent study by Warwick Business School found that women outperform men by 1.8% annually by focusing on the long term with a more diversified portfolio. Women’s strong behavioural controls means they remain composed when markets are volatile. “They tend to trade less and build more diversified portfolios,” Talbot says. “They remain focused on the longer-term and their specific financial goals. And these behaviours tend to lower costs, limit mistakes and keep the focus on the end-goal.”

It’s a best practice Talbot advises for all clients – not only women. “I always discourage clients from jumping in and out of strategies or reacting to short-term fluctuations,” she says. And for good reason. “Chasing returns and bailing at the first dip can derail a portfolio and cause you to miss key rebound days. That’s why staying focused on the long term is typically the better path.”

They’re more likely to favour values-aligned investments

women and investing

If there’s a silver lining to the financial challenges women face, it’s that they often develop a deeper sense of empathy – and many choose to channel that empathy into aligning their investments with their values.

Studies have shown that women prefer values-based investments, and are nearly twice as likely as men to consider ESG factors in their investment decisions. 

“Women are increasingly demanding strategies where they can use their investments to support companies that share their values – and that are making a positive impact on society,” Talbot says. “Many of my female clients prefer investing in companies driving positive environmental and social change.”

They’re up against persistent investment myths

women invest

A lot of would-be investors stop before they start, held back by familiar myths: that investing is risky, complicated or only for the wealthy.

Feeling hesitant is normal, but it’s time we bust these myths. “Of course there’s no guarantee with investing, but not investing can be the riskier approach over time,” Talbot says.

You also don’t need a lot of money to start: you can set up automatic deposits – even $25 a month – so it’s easy and consistent. 

And you don’t have to be an expert: a good advisor can guide you through the complexities and help you make informed decisions that align with your goals.

The bottom line: when women invest with knowledge and support, they grow both their wealth and their confidence – and that’s exactly what we’re committed to making happen.

They’re often underserved by wealth managers

women advisors

A recent report revealed that women are 2.5 times more likely to request working with women advisors. But only 15 to 20% of advisors are women. “In my experience, women prioritize trust and alignment when choosing a financial advisor,” Talbot says. “They want someone who can truly understand their needs.” 

A straightforward solution is better representation in the financial sector: hire more women and maintain a better balance so clients can pick the advisor who feels like the right fit. 

At Genus, we’ve made gender equity a priority – 50% of our staff are women so we can better serve our clients. But we go even further, prioritizing education, clear communication and personalized guidance with every client. 

“Education is a big part of my work – and if that means spending extra time with newer investors, I’m all for it,” Talbot says. “The most rewarding part is the transformation: someone starts out unsure, and a year later they’re confident, comfortable with their portfolio, and making informed decisions. Seeing that growth is truly the highlight of my job.”

Interested in exploring how to meet your investing goals? Get started today with our des services d'investissement fondés sur des valeurs.

This document is provided for general information purposes only and is not a substitute for professional advice. It does not constitute investment, legal, accounting, tax, or other advice or recommendations, nor should it be relied upon as the basis for any decision. Readers should seek specific professional guidance before making financial or investment decisions. Certain information herein is based on third-party sources believed to be reliable, but its accuracy and completeness are not guaranteed. Past performance is not a guarantee of future results.

Références : 

  1. Client challenge. (n.d.-b). https://www.ft.com/content/9b60c729-f6fb-4eb9-bfe7-1290a38b4677

  2. Are women better investors than men? | News | Warwick Business School. (n.d.). Warwick Business School. https://www.wbs.ac.uk/news/are-women-better-investors-than-men/

  3. The gender investment gap. (2023, March 13). https://www.fidelity.ca/en/insights/articles/gender-investment-gap/

  4. Rising expenses hurting Canadian women’s retirement security. (n.d.). Default. https://hoopp.com/news-and-insights/newsroom/newsroom-details/rising-expenses-hurting-canadian-women-s-retirement-security

  5. Are women better investors than men? | News | Warwick Business School. (n.d.-b). Warwick Business School. https://www.wbs.ac.uk/news/are-women-better-investors-than-men/

  6. Dr. Daniel Crosby, & Lara Coviello. (2022, August 24). Why Women Are The Ultimate Behavioral Investors. FA Mag. Retrieved October 22, 2025, from https://www.fa-mag.com/news/why-women-are-the-ultimate-behavioral-investors-69377.html?print

  7. Iacurci, G. (2022, June 24). Women prefer values-based investing. Here’s what that might mean for their wealth. CNBC. https://www.cnbc.com/2022/06/24/women-prefer-values-based-investing-heres-how-that-impacts-their-wealth.html

  8. ESG momentum is slowing for many investors, but not for women. (2023, March 11). Financialpost. https://financialpost.com/investing/esg-momentum-not-slowing-women-investors

  9. News releases. (n.d.). https://www.sunlife.com/en/newsroom/news-releases/announcement/only-15-of-financial-advisors-in-canada-are-women-while-womens-share-of-wealth-assets-expected-to-double-by-2028/123720/
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Courriel

Client impact

"Passer d'une grande banque à Genus a été l'une des meilleures décisions financières que nous ayons jamais prises. Genus a assuré une croissance fiable des actifs malgré notre tolérance modérée au risque. Alors que notre sécurité financière s'est accrue, nous avons également bénéficié d'une excellente expérience client. Les communications de la société ont toujours été transparentes et informatives, y compris les webinaires éducatifs et un portail Web bien conçu où nous pouvons suivre nos investissements quotidiennement. Le plus important pour nous est que notre gestionnaire de portefeuille a toujours répondu rapidement et de manière exhaustive à nos questions et à nos demandes. "
Martin T.
"Ayant des objectifs et des besoins financiers relativement divers, ainsi qu'une légère réticence à l'égard du marché boursier, Genus a habilement répondu à toutes nos préoccupations et a mis au point un plan vraiment exceptionnel : Des fonds sans combustibles fossiles et un portefeuille d'investissement diversifié, oui ; un portefeuille d'investissement à impact efficace qui coïncide avec nos espoirs et nos rêves d'un monde meilleur, oui ; des conseils et une assistance professionnels pour créer un fonds de bienfaisance conseillé par le donateur avec des reçus de bienfaisance immédiats à des fins fiscales, oui. Les résultats ? Bien au-delà de nos espérances ! Nous nous sommes même amusés en cours de route et nous avons certainement profité d'un incroyable départ de deux ans pour ce qui sera une relation satisfaisante à long terme avec Genus.
Marc B.
"J'aime le service que je reçois chez Genus.
Chris H.
"Leslie et moi étions membres du même conseil d'administration lorsque nous nous sommes rencontrés il y a vingt ans. Au cours des dix dernières années, elle a réfléchi à l'élaboration d'une stratégie d'investissement pour ma famille et l'a mise en œuvre comme prévu. L'équipe de Genus a répondu à mes attentes et c'est un plaisir de traiter avec elle".
Bob Q.
"Pendant plus de 15 ans, j'ai assuré la sélection et l'évaluation des performances de plusieurs gestionnaires d'investissement pour un important family office. Leslie et Genus ont joué un rôle fondamental dans ma fonction. J'ai toujours trouvé que Leslie et ses collègues étaient perspicaces et proactifs, et que la performance de leur part du portefeuille était bien supérieure aux indices de référence. Et c'est un grand plaisir de travailler avec eux".
Douglas H.
"Genus est une société très innovante. Je suis heureux d'investir dans leurs stratégies Fossil Free et Impact qui m'aident à investir en accord avec mes valeurs."
Marnie C.
"Excellente équipe de professionnels. Site web et rapports excellents. Répond rapidement aux demandes de renseignements. Je suis également très satisfait du processus de changement d'une autre société à Genus. Bravo !".
David L.
"Genus fournit toujours une bonne image, clairement expliquée et complète de la situation économique et financière générale, ainsi qu'un excellent compte-rendu des décisions d'investissement prises en fonction de cette situation. L'intérêt tout aussi marqué de Genus pour les questions et les demandes d'informations complémentaires de ses clients est également un élément très important du service qu'il fournit".
Allan S.
"En 1992, lorsque je me suis retrouvé à cinquante ans avec une somme d'argent importante à investir, je ne savais qu'une chose : je ne voulais pas contribuer aux compagnies de tabac, aux fabricants d'armes ou aux compagnies pétrolières. Mais au cours des années qui ont suivi, les options d'investissement socialement responsable sont devenues beaucoup plus sophistiquées et je suis très heureux que cela fasse partie intégrante de l'approche de Genus. J'apprécie également beaucoup la relation à long terme avec ma gestionnaire de portefeuille, Mary Lou.
Ann P.

Comme vu dans

Prêt.e à avoir un impact avec vos investissements?

Appelez-nous
Appelez-nous
1-800-668-7366

Ou remplissez vos coordonnées et nous vous contacterons.